Suspended Oaths: Germans and Italians

December 1941

Dearest Reader,

In a letter dated December 13, 1941, just six days after the attack on Pearl Harbor, my grandmother recorded how quickly the war reached into ordinary lives. My father was living in Saginaw, Michigan at the time, having just turned twenty-one, and the country was still reeling from the shock of December 7. The United States was suddenly at war, and uncertainty permeated even the most routine aspects of life.

In the midst of the upheaval, my grandmother noted an event that might seem small but speaks volumes about the atmosphere of fear and urgency that followed Pearl Harbor. She wrote:

“Sr Hilda was supposed to be naturalized Monday, but Atty General Biddle issued orders to all judges in the U.S. that no Germans or Italians could be naturalized, so they left her out.”

Within days of Pearl Harbor, the Department of Justice moved swiftly to classify German, Italian and Japanese nationals who were not yet citizens as “enemy aliens”. As part of these emergency wartime measures, naturalization ceremonies for Germans and Italians were abruptly suspended across the country. Judges were instructed to exclude them from citizenship proceedings, even when individuals had already completed the process and were scheduled to be sworn in.

The Attorney General she refers to was Francis Biddle, who had taken office earlier that year under President Franklin D. Roosevelt. His department oversaw internal security during the war’s opening days, issuing directives that reshaped immigration, citizenship and civil liberties almost overnight. There was no single, named law but a rapid series of administrative orders that reflected the nation’s fear.

For Sr. Hilda, and for countless others like her, this meant exclusion without warning. Citizenship, which had seemed imminent, was suddenly postponed indefinitely, not because of personal conduct, but because of birthplace.

Set alongside her questions to my father about registration and the draft, this moment reveals how swiftly the landscape of American life. In a single letter, she captures a country pivoting under pressure. 

Sincerely, Nancy Watson

Dr. Nancy Watson

Rambling With Nan

Washington