The American Mercury: From Literary Criticism to Political Commentary

1924

Dearest Reader,

The American Mercury began in 1924, founded by journalist and critic H. L. Mencken and theater critic George Jean Nathan, with Alfred A. Knopf as publisher. The two editors had previously worked together on The Smart Set. Their new magazine brought together literature, reporting, humor, and criticism of American society.

“Mercury” belonged to a longstanding tradition of publication names associated with delivering news and ideas. Mencken also liked the title’s respectable sound. In explaining the choice to writer Theodore Dreiser, he described wanting a dignified exterior that would leave room for provocative material inside.

The early magazine had a distinctly libertarian streak. It challenged censorship, Prohibition, moral policing, and efforts to regulate private behavior. Its criticism frequently targeted the hypocrisy of people who claimed authority over how others should live. This placed it at odds with many socially conservative attitudes of the 1920s.

Its opposition to censorship became national news in 1926. After Boston authorities banned an issue containing Herbert Asbury’s “Hatrack,” a story involving a prostitute and religious hypocrisy, Mencken deliberately sold a copy in the city. His arrest turned the dispute into a public confrontation over freedom of expression.

The magazine also challenged cultural conformity and narrow ideas about whose experiences belonged in print. Contributors included Dorothy Parker and James Weldon Johnson, alongside people writing from occupations and circumstances far removed from established literary circles. Mencken’s own sharp, mocking commentary helped make it a prominent publication.

Calling it libertarian describes part of its outlook, but not a consistent political platform. Mencken distrusted government activism while also expressing contempt for mass democracy. His individualism existed alongside political elitism. The magazine’s varied contents resist a simple identification with today’s liberal or conservative camps.

Mencken retired as editor in 1933. Later editors and owners reshaped the publication, and around 1950 William Bradford Huie gave it an explicitly conservative direction. Anti-communism became an important theme. Businessman Russell Maguire acquired it in 1952, introducing another consequential change in leadership.

Under Maguire, the magazine moved further right. Editorial disputes followed, including resignations in 1955 amid concerns about the introduction of antisemitic material. These developments marked a substantial departure from the magazine’s earlier literary identity and cannot be explained by Cold War fears alone. Ownership and editorial decisions shaped its course.

The original print magazine ceased publication in 1981. A separate online revival using the name began in 2010. Its history therefore encompasses several distinct publications under one title: an influential literary and cultural review, a conservative political magazine, and a later extremist direction that damaged its reputation.

Sincerely, Nancy Watson

Dr. Nancy Watson

Washington